By some means, Beth Dutton lived her entire life on the Yellowstone Ranch but didn’t know what her dad, brothers and husband were as much as on the train station.

This baffling revelation from Season 5, Ep. 8 closes what was the largest plot hole on Yellowstone. She’d been blackmailing her brother Jamie Dutton because she thought having photo evidence of him dumping his murdered birth father’s body was enough to sink him, should he not do exactly what she wanted.

Jamie literally laughed at that through the mid-season as thousands and thousands of viewers shouted, “She didn’t know!?” The Dutton Rules team discuss this and so way more during this week’s podcast episode:

In fact, viewers knew what was at the underside of a cliff the Duttons call the “train station.” As John Dutton explains, it’s where his family has been depositing the bodies for a long time. Consider it as a garbage can, except he’s normally the one who decides what’s and is not trash.

So, should Beth tattle on her brother, he’d be inclined to return the favor. While the fictional and (semi) nonfictional explanation of this lawless land leads one to consider you may get away with anything, nobody seems willing to check it.

The mid-season finale of Season 5 of Yellowstone includes dueling plans to kill off the opposite, and each are problematic. Dutton Rules hosts Adison Haager and Billy Dukes explain why before reflecting on Kayce Dutton’s big revelation, Jimmy’s romantic return and Ep. 3 of 1923.

For those who think Harrison Ford is leaving 1923, re-evaluate. There’s reason to consider that Jacob survives, despite it looking awful.

Thanks a lot for listening. Find Dutton Rules on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, or wherever you podcast. It’s also possible to listen on the above player.